The transcript has been transcribed and edited from English simultaneous interpretation, thus there may be potential semantic inaccuracies within it.
Daily Morning Lesson: November 19, 2026
Part 1: Rabash. What Is the Foundation on which Kedusha [Holiness] Is Built? Article No. 16, 1988.
Reader: Shalom. In the first part of the lesson, we will study a lesson by Rav from February 7, 2002. It's a second lesson from a series of two lessons based on the article, What Is the Foundation on Which Kedusha, Holiness, Is Built? You can find the article in the writings of Rabash, first volume, page 654 in Hebrew. We will read together in the Tens, starting with page 657, beginning with, Now we can interpret the dispute between the herdsmen of Gerar and the herdsmen of Isaac, up to, Before he came to work in the right line. Again, beginning in Hebrew, it's page 657, beginning with, From now we can interpret, and up to 662, final words, Before he came to work in the right line." We have 35 minutes, let's start.
Reading: (01:06) What Is the Foundation on which Kedusha [Holiness] Is Built? -continued.
Now we can interpret the dispute between the herdsmen of Gerar and the herdsmen of Isaac, as it is written, “And Isaac's servants dug ... and the herdsmen of Gerar quarreled with the herdsmen of Isaac... So he named the well Oshek, because they Hitashku [contended] with him. And they dug another well, and they quarreled over it, too, and he named it Sitnah [Hebrew: enmity]. And [he] dug another well, and they did not quarrel over it; and he named it Rehovot ... And he went up from there to Beersheba.”
We must understand the meaning of “Herdsmen of” in spirituality, and the difference between “the herdsmen of Gerar” and “the herdsmen of Isaac” in the work, as well as why there was a quarrel over the digging of the first two wells and none over the digging of the third well, as it is written, “And they did not quarrel over it.”
It is known that one cannot live without provision. “Provision” is considered that which sustains one in life and of which he says, “This is worth living for.” Certainly, there are many degrees of man’s provision. Some are content with little, meaning that if a person has the food that animals settle for, he says, “This is enough for me and such provision is worth living for.” Compared to the provision of others, he is regarded as settling for little.
And some say that they settle for such nourishments that are enough to provide for little children. This is an addition to animals, since they have interests: they play hide-and-seek, with toys and so on. They settle for this and say, “What we enjoy does not have to be real. Even if it is a lie, we can still find our provision there.” On the contrary, it is the real things that we find completely meaningless.
As an allegory, I said many times that we see that there are little girls whose parents bought them rag dolls to play with. Sometimes, the mother is in the kitchen preparing a meal, with a year-old baby in the house, and the baby is crying. The mother says to her little girl, “Go play with the baby. By that, the baby will enjoy and I will enjoy because I will be able to prepare the meal.”
But we see that in reality, the girl will not go. If we were to ask the girl, “Why don’t you want to play with the baby? You’re only playing with your doll, kissing it, but why won’t you play with a real baby instead of a baby made of rags? Moreover, you can see that your mother is doing the opposite. She never kisses your doll, but the real baby.” The girl would probably answer, “My mother does not want to enjoy life; this is why she cannot play with a doll. But I still want to enjoy life, so I can’t play with a real baby.”
Similarly, in the work, one cannot enjoy the truth in the work. Rather, man is impressed specifically with lies and takes pleasure and liveliness from this. If he is told, “It is unbecoming for you to enjoy work with unreal things,” he says, “I still want to enjoy the world; this is why I settle for little in my engagement in Torah and Mitzvot.”
For the most part, each person in the general public that observes the holy work and observes Torah and Mitzvot chooses his own measure of time he must dedicate to Torah and Mitzvot. Each one measures for himself what he understands as sufficient for him in both quantity and quality, and says that he settles for little. He does not have to be among the wealthy, who have great possessions. Instead, each understands his measure in Torah and Mitzvot with good reason.
It is as The Zohar says about the verse, “Her husband is known at the gates,” each according to what he measures in his heart. This means that according to the greatness of the Creator that he measures in his heart, he knows how much time he must dedicate to Torah and Mitzvot and how much he must exert if it is hard for him to observe the Torah and Mitzvot.
However, there are a chosen few who do not settle for the provisions of the general public. According to the ARI, the dissatisfaction that they feel is a matter of the root of the soul. They need to advance more than the general public, and they begin to understand that the main work should be to sustain themselves on man’s food, not on the food of beasts or the food given to little ones. As Maimonides puts it, “When teaching the little ones, they are taught to work for a reward, and they are not told of the matter of Lishma [for Her sake].”
However, here begins the main exertion, when he wishes to go by the path of bestowal upon the Creator and not for his own benefit, and to this, the body resists. Then he begins to think thoughts that wish to make him see that “You don’t need to be an exception. As others settle for the provision of reward for labor in this world and in the next world, this should be enough for you, too. Why are you making a fuss about wanting to work specifically in a manner of bestowal? Can’t you see that this is difficult? If it weren’t, others would work in bestowal, too.” With these arguments, these thoughts seal the diggings, meaning the deficiencies and the need to obtain the desire to bestow.
Now we can interpret what are “The herdsmen of Gerar,” “The herdsmen of Isaac,” and what is the dispute between them. “Herdsman” means provider. “The herdsmen of Gerar” means that their provision is in following the crowd. In other words, thoughts come to them that they do not need to work like the work of the few, who wish to reach the truth, called Lishma, meaning in order to bestow. Instead, they settle for being workers who observe Torah and Mitzvot to receive reward in this world and in the next world. This means that here, too, in observing Torah and Mitzvot, he can follow a path of settling for little.
“The herdsmen of Isaac” means what sustains Isaac. This is considered sustaining the quality of Isaac, the quality of bestowal. As long as he can bestow upon the Creator, this is his provision, and from this he makes a living.
That was the quarrel between the herdsmen of Gerar, who were telling him that any digging to find deficiency and need to engage only in the path of bestowal is not worth digging and searching for such deficiencies. They seal the need by saying, “We must follow the masses and not be exceptions.”
The herdsmen of Isaac dug and looked for a need and deficiency to find pain and suffering from not being able to do things with the aim to bestow. This means that they understood that the most important thing was to work in bestowal, and they did not feel pain and suffering from this deficiency. Thus, they dug and sought advice concerning how to feel suffering, and the herdsmen of Gerar came and blocked the deficiencies that they had found. In other words, they promoted the understanding that it is not so terrible; we can follow the masses who say, “We are content with little.”
This caused suffering to Isaac’s herdsmen, since they had made great efforts to find that their deficiencies could not work in bestowal and to be pained by it. And they were already able to pray from the bottom of the heart, and they already had a place of blessing, meaning to give thanks to the Creator for showing them a place of lack, which is the most important in the work of the Creator. In other words, if they cannot aim the actions to benefit the Creator, they are not considered servants of the Creator, but their own servants. And the herdsmen of Gerar suddenly came and pulled them to follow the provision of the masses. By this they sealed all the well of Isaac’s herdsmen, and this is the issue with the quarrel that they had between them over the digging of the wells.
Now we will explain what we asked: Why did the herdsmen of Gerar quarrel over the first two wells and did not quarrel over the third well? It is known that the order of the work is in three lines—right and left, which are opposite to one another, and then comes the middle line and peace is made.
It is also known, as we said, that the masses belong to a single line. Therefore, there is no one to oppose him, to make contradictory arguments, since he has only one line. This is why the matter of ascents and descents hardly applies to them. But with the right line, the left line stands opposite it. Therefore, in the right line there are already ascents and descents.
It is known that the right line is a line of truth. A single line, however, is not so true. Also, it is known that anything that is far from the truth is easier to observe. This is why the way of the masses, who are taught to go by a single line, means that they have not come to know and understand that there is more than actions. Rather, when they observe the 613 Mitzvot, they aim that the Creator commanded us to observe them, by which we will receive reward, and this is a complete righteous.
The only distinction among the workers is in quantity, in the amount of time each one gives for his engagement in Torah and Mitzvot. Therefore, since he is not so close to the truth, to being in Lo Lishma [not for Her sake], there aren’t that many ascents and descents in those states, called “provision of the masses,” since if he only believes in reward and punishment, to the extent of his faith, the body agrees to work and to exert in observing Torah and Mitzvot, for the reward he expects to receive in his vessels of reception are not in contrast with the body, called “will to receive for himself.” Thus, they can work with great diligence.
There is another reason why there aren’t so many descents in them: They find success in the work. In other words, they see that each day they advance in Torah and Mitzvot. It is human nature that when we see that we succeed in some work, there is motivation to work. All this is considered one line.
This is not so when a person begins to work in order to bestow, meaning when the reward he expects to receive in return for his work is to obtain Dvekut [adhesion] with the Creator, when his intention in observing Torah and Mitzvot is to have only the desire to bestow upon the Creator and not for himself. And as much as he exerts to be rewarded with vessels of bestowal, he does not move an inch. On the contrary, he sees that he is not succeeding in the work. Thus, from where will he receive livelihood so he can continue with the work?
The correction is to know the truth: that he is still immersed in self-love and he is still remote from the Creator. But then he must tell himself, “Although I still do not see any progress in the work, I have the great privilege of being able to do something in Torah and Mitzvot.”
Then he must believe above reason that although he still does not feel His greatness, doing little things in Torah and Mitzvot—even if by coercion—makes him happy that he has some grip in Torah and Mitzvot. And for that he is grateful to the Creator. This is considered that the gratitude he gives to the Creator is given in truth.
In other words, he knows the truth—that he is remote from the Creator—yet he is happy that he has the strength to do something in Torah and Mitzvot, although he is not doing it wholeheartedly. But what is important to him is that he is serving the Creator, even though he still does not feel the greatness of the Creator. Nevertheless, he is thankful to the Creator for allowing him to do anything for Him.
And this is true. He is not deceiving himself into thinking that he is regarded as a servant of the Creator because he knows the truth, that everything he does is completely by coercion and not willingly.
But those who walk on a single line, who thank the Creator for rewarding them with engaging in Torah and Mitzvot, there are two drawbacks there: 1) One considers himself a worker of the Creator, and this is not the truth, since he is working for himself. 2) The Creator is not the one who is important in his eyes, meaning that it is worthwhile to work for the Creator. Rather, all the importance of the work is in how much reward he will receive for his labor. In other words, he is looking at the reward—whether he will receive a weighty salary—and not whether the giver of the salary is important.
But those who go by the right line consider the giver of the work, how important He is to them. Their desire is always that the giver of the work will be important to them, and this is their reward. This is considered that they always long to see the greatness of the Creator.
It follows that they are not after the reward they will receive for their work. Rather, when they observe His commandments, they always look to see that the commander, the Giver of the commandments, will be more important in their eyes each time, and this is their reward in their exertion in Torah and Mitzvot. For this reason, they say that even a small grip in Torah and Mitzvot is a great thing, and they are delighted and receive livelihood.
Now we can explain the quarrel over the first digging, since the matter of the three diggings comprises the whole work. In other words, there are many diggings that belong to the right line, many diggings that belong to the left line, and many diggings that belong to the middle line. The reason for it is that not all the diggings can be done at one time. Rather, in each line there is much to dig until the lines are acquired in full.
Concerning the first well that they dug, it is written, “And he named the well Oshek, because they Hitashku [contended] with him.” We should explain Oshek. It means that with the first well, which implies the right line, they engaged in Torah and Mitzvot in these diggings.
This is so because the right line is called “wholeness,” since the left line is called “deficiency.” Right is called “wholeness,” meaning that in the right, they had the strength to engage in Torah and Mitzvot with joy for the above-mentioned reason: Whatever grip they have in Torah and Mitzvot, they believe that it comes to them from above, that the Creator gave them the desire and craving to be able to engage a little in Torah and Mitzvot. This is why the herdsmen of Isaac argued, “Whatever grip we have, it is important to us and we thank the Creator for it.”
Conversely, the herdsmen of Gerar were following what the masses say: “We observe Torah and Mitzvot by our own strength, and for this reason, we demand of the Creator to pay for our labor in Torah and Mitzvot.” By this they seal the well that the servants of Isaac had dug, who said, “We can receive vitality from here because even a small thing is important to us, meaning that the Creator gave us the desire and craving to do anything in the work of the Creator. But we see that there are people who do not have the desire and craving to do anything in the work, since the Creator did not give them this desire.”
This is why the servants of Isaac received life from this well. The herdsmen of Gerar came and sealed that well so they would not be able to receive life from there. They would tell them, “Your insistence on this inferior work is worthless. You will not receive any reward for it because it is completely unimportant, since the majority of people regard it as inferior.”
This is why in the first well, which they called Oshek [contending], they said, “It is not contention that it is worthwhile rejoicing with this petite work, about which you are making a fuss. After all, there is nothing to look at, as you yourselves are saying that it is only a very small work. And your focus on the Giver—this, we do not understand.”
Afterward, the herdsmen of Isaac’s servants shifted to working on the left line, criticizing their situation, that they are still immersed in self-love. They see that they are unable to work for the Creator by themselves; hence, they dig in the bottom of their hearts to find deficiencies and pain. In other words, they seek advice how to feel suffering over being remote from the path of bestowal. And certainly, when they have suffering, they will receive help from the Creator, as during the exodus from Egypt, as it is written, “And the children of Israel sighed from the work ... and God heard their groaning.”
Thus, by digging into the bottom of their hearts, they found a well, meaning a place where they could pray. “And they quarreled over it, too, and he named it Sitnah [enmity].” This means that the herdsmen of Gerar became their slanderers, not letting them pray that the Creator would fulfill their wish, meaning that the Creator would grant them the strength to overcome the vessels of reception so they could work for the sake of the Creator and not for themselves.
It follows that through their quarrel, they sealed the diggings they had dug in the left line so they would have a need for the Creator to grant their wishes favorably. “Good” means in order to bestow, as it is written, “My heart overflows with a good thing. I say, ‘My deeds are for the King.’” The meaning of “My deeds are for the King” is that everything he does will be for the King, that his intention is to bestow upon the King.
And the herdsmen of Gerar were their slanderers so they would not be able to pray because they were following the majority saying, “The act is what counts, and the intention of doing it Lishma is not our business. Rather, it is for people who are pure at heart and gifted from birth. And the work in bestowal is not for us.” Thus, they sealed off the need for prayer. This is why they called the second well, Sitnah, from the word Satan [which also means “slandering”].
And in that line, too, they did not make the second well in a single time. Rather, they dug many times in each line. However, all of them, meaning all the diggings, fall under the name of the three wells.
But afterwards, once they completed the process of work in two lines, they were rewarded with the middle line. It is as we said in previous essays, that the right line is called “his father,” the left line is “his mother,” and the middle line is called “the Creator,” as it is written, “Three partake in man—his father, his mother, and the Creator.”
“His father gives the white.” This means that there is no deficiency there. Rather, everything is white, meaning that he is content with his lot, with the little grip on spirituality that he has.
“His mother gives the red.” This means that he is not in a good situation, but is rather filled with deficiencies, and then he has room for prayer.
Afterward, “The Creator gives the soul.” When the Creator helps him, giving him the soul, Satan no longer has room, meaning he has nothing to slander. This is the meaning of the words, “And [he] dug another well, and they did not quarrel over it; and he called its name Rehovot, for ‘At last the Lord has made room for us...’ And he went up from there to Beersheba.”
We asked, “What is the reason that the herdsmen of Gerar did not quarrel over the third well?” Where there is a deficiency in Kedusha [holiness], there is room for the Sitra Achra. Hence, when a person goes on the right line, when he knows that he is immersed in self-love and all of his actions are not for the Creator, but he wants to be a worker of the Creator and in the meantime he is serving himself, and despite all the baseness that he is in, he wants to thank the Creator for giving him some contact with the work of the Creator, even if it is Lo Lishma.
And he believes above reason that the Creator gave him the thought and desire to engage a little in the work. Since he believes as much as he can in the greatness and importance of the Creator, above reason, although he was not rewarded with feeling the importance within reason, he still has the privilege of doing simple things. He is thankful and praises the Creator, and he is delighted and wishes to thank the Creator like those people who are in one line, meaning those who feel that the work they are doing is truly in wholeness and all they need to add is in quantity.
In quality, however, they feel that they are so complete that they need to work on humbleness, as our sages said, “Be very, very humble.” They exert much work in this, in finding some lowliness in themselves, and it is all because they know only one line. This is the work of the masses.
But one who wishes to go by the right line, who knows that there is a left line, too, which weakens the right line, must make great efforts to believe above reason that even a little work in spirituality—even if incomplete, as they themselves feel—is important. Also, he must thank the Creator and be happy, and feel that now he has a life worth living for.
This means that by believing above reason that there is no end to the greatness of the Creator, and it is very important for him that he can serve the King, this is called “right line.” This is a lot of work, and one should feel that the work in the right line is important. He should strive to have the same extent of vitality as when he was working in a single line, or at least no less than when he was working in a single line, before he came to work in the right line.
___________________________________
Reader: Now let's enter Rav's lesson.
M. Laitman: (36:10) We're in the middle, continuing the article, What Is the Foundation on Which Holiness Is Built? We read a few pages and did not finish. Rabash would write such – some articles over several weeks – and we also read them in parts. Are there any questions?
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (36:41) The right line is always called, The line of truth, and yet they say that we walk on the middle line?
M. Laitman: Truth is called the right line, the middle line is not the truth; the middle line is a compromise. Meaning that you can say it is called truth according to my strengths for the time being, but it's not called the absolute truth. The absolute truth is in the right line. If I could become 100% similar to the right line with all my left line, that would be the absolute truth. But I'm not able to, so I make a compromise, I work in order to bestow as much as I am able, and that's all. Therefore, the middle line is still a result of the effort.
If the left line shifts completely into the right line and they become truly one line, not the middle line but they return to being one line. Just as the three lines return in Akudim to one line, when the world of Atzilut, with the worlds of BYA rises above the Tabur of AK and ascend to root to the world of the root, to the world of AK, to Ein Sof. Then it is truly truth there, what does this mean? It means that the created being, without any calculations and without considering what it has, is incorporated in the Creator, is similar to Him, and becomes like Him, this is truly truth, that's it. So the middle line is still a result of the corrections.
Student: The state of the end of correction still belongs 100% to the line of truth, to the right line, or to the right line?
M. Laitman: The end of correction means that the left line and the right line literally become one line. It's not the middle line, but one line, as in AK. They become one to such an extent that, after that, we have the correction of the stony heart, where there are no lines at all. Instead, the same Malchut of Ein Sof, all of it, although it is in an area, its area is like a circle, but its circle no longer comes from having no boundary on the part of the light. Rather, there's no boundary on the part of the vessel, in the vessel's reception. That is, we return to the circle, what is a circle? It is when all the desires are corrected with a screen. Then again, the vessel is not limited anywhere or in any direction. It is not in the square form that comes about for us in one line; it's not in a triangular form that came about in the second restriction; instead, everything returns to no boundary because there is a screen over all the qualities of the created being.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (40:22) There is a line, there's a right line, there's a left line, and there's a middle line. Which lines do you build through the group, and which lines do you need the help from the Creator? When does the Creator enter the picture?
M. Laitman: When does the Creator enter the picture? When He's allowed to enter – I'm saying this seriously! When? There is no such thing, man performs all kinds of actions in the study, in the group, in all kinds of efforts, wherever he can, so as to truly shift himself towards belonging, to walking on the path towards the goal. As a result, he begins to enter darkness, sometimes he's given light, a little illumination. All in all, after the period of double concealment, he enters a period of single concealment. In the period of single concealment, he no longer hears what he's told. He already begins to understand by himself, to understand how he's being worked on.
He also sees the Creator a little, how He turns all things around for him. He also sees his own nature and feels his own nature – how much he nevertheless does not agree with what the Creator does to him. Although, from the side of holiness, he sees that one must do such and such, but from his own side he sees that he's unable to do it – this is called single concealment. Then he's always in an inner struggle like this, an inner tension. This is a very uncomfortable state, but a juicy one, he truly sees both sides and cannot decide in favor of holiness. Sometimes, for a moment, he's allowed to think that way a little, but usually not. Still, I have no choice I'm going to steal. He knows it is forbidden, and still he does it.
If he makes the correct efforts and still gives up on, he wants strength, he demands it from the books, from holiness, from the group, from everything. Then somehow, he tries to shift himself and cling to the right line. But the right line, here, means that one has to act not according to reason, not according to what life seems to tell him, but above it. It is a foolish act, as it were, not according to the correct calculation of what he sees in life, that is a problem. So a long time passes until truly all the bitterness takes shape inside of him. Since he's unable to rise even a little above his beastly nature in favor of the spirituality, the holiness, the godliness he sees. This applies to the simplest things and to the greatest things that can be, this is called faith above reason.
In the preparation period, you see your body, your mind and your beastly nature, and the whole world says the same, You must do such and such, and guard everything in such and such a way. And right next to it you see that spirituality, godliness, is not like that. It is above it – step over these calculations. A person who wages these struggles gradually is rewarded that he reaches a decision that he must ask the Creator for help. That is, this does not end with him succeeding, either, but from all of the successes and disappointments, the more he succeeds, the more he comes to a state where he does not succeed and he must ask.
M. Laitman: (45:48) And here, too, there must be a very tight guidance because a person can do foolish things, here. He can go with faith below reason instead of faith above reason. It will seem to him that he is already doing deeds of a complete righteous, so as not to do foolish things, here. In ordinary life, in life's events, he begins to spend, you know, throw away his money or starts doing the opposite or something, or throws himself out of his workplace or out of some relationship. So, here, truly intensive care is needed but gradually everything is arranged from above. He comes to a state where he cries out for, Save me, as it is written, here. He cries out to the Creator, not to someone else, and then he receives help.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (47:04) The article says to keep looking for advice on how to obtain the greatness and importance of the Creator. So, what advice can we get?
M. Laitman: We learn that our reality is a will to receive that yearns for pleasures in all kinds of ways. The will to receive can be corrected to take on some other consideration, only if the will to receive feels dependent on something. What does, On something mean? Let's say that it does not receive pleasures, how do we teach a person, You want something? I won't give it to you. Why? Because I don't want to. Then he's dependent on you. Now you can set him conditions, you will give him what he wants in exchange for whatever you want to receive from him. I want to live, I want to eat, and I have no choice. If the employer or someone who has money will not give it to me, I give in and ask, I'm ready to work for you so that you give me a little pleasure, right? That's how it is, we subdue the will to receive, otherwise, would I go to work or do anything at all?
Now, the Creator is hidden, if He were revealed, it would be like everything else in life, we would see that He is great and that I depend on Him. I depend on You, I take off my hat and subdue myself, Please help me, and so on – the will to receive works in a simple way. All its calculations about pride and about all kinds of things, ultimately, all these calculations accumulate into what is called, pleasure. So, pleasure is money or honor or knowledge or beastly lusts, it doesn't matter what, it is still pleasure. There is a more basic pleasure and a more exalted pleasure. The closer it is to the beast level, to the foundation, the more the pleasure is; or the more strongly we feel the sufferings in us, that's it.
Don't let some professor eat and he will forget about his science. All the time he will only think, How will I eat, you understand? No problem. This is why Aristotle says that the problem with today's professors is that they want to eat well and they also want science. So, in exchange for good food, you can buy his science. Then they ask him, Develop a bomb for me, and he does it in exchange for good food – he does everything, that's it.
M. Laitman: (50:36) So, if the Creator were revealed, we would have no problem. We would run to Him to work for Him and receive the best things. Why would I work for someone else? To reach, in order to bestow, it is precisely necessary that He be hidden but what do I gain from His being hidden? How do I replace my intention to in order to bestow? I need to receive some force from Him, without His being revealed; if He’s revealed, I'm already addicted to the pleasure that comes from Him. I need to be addicted to the knowledge, itself, to the idea, right? To the purpose, to the very idea of, in order to bestow. How can this be done? We need, we must be brought to a state where it is precisely corrections that we will want instead of pleasures. It must be to a point where I say, Bring me all the pleasures, no, I want corrections, I don't want pleasures.
How is that possible? After all, wanting pleasures is my nature. How will I want some corrections, some intentions in order to bestow instead? These intentions are entirely in my mind, not in the vessels of reception. So, this is possible only through suffering, the vessels of reception are given suffering to the point where they are in a state where it is better not to use them. At the same time, pleasures and suffering are also given in the intention: with in order to bestow, I first feel suffering, and with in order to receive, I feel pleasure. Through suffering in the intentions too, I gradually begin to want intentions in order to bestow, and to suffer for my intentions in order to receive.
Look at these two systems, bitter and sweet, and truth and falsehood; look at the reversal that both of them have to go through. Both of them have to go through it and this is done literally through something a person understands. What does he understand? Either a blow or a candy. So, in the beastly system, bitter and sweet, and in the human system, truth and falsehood, we must go through some development until the Creator receives them. This helps us, it helps us to gradually restrict the system of bitter and sweet. And in the system of truth and falsehood, demand only the truth in order to bestow, that's it, so concealment is necessary.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (54:28) Concealment is necessary, as for the greatest importance of the Creator, it has to be the real work now?
M. Laitman: Now, how do I change my intention from in order to receive to in order to bestow? How do I get myself to think this way through the greatness of the Creator, what does the greatness of the Creator give me? Well, He's great – well, what do I care whether He's great or small? Does that give me any pleasure, what does it mean, the greatness of the Creator? That He is great, I don't know whether He's great or small, suppose I see Him as great, what does that do in me? How am I impressed by it, what does it add to which system in mine? That is the question. The will to receive is built so that it comes as a result of the Upper One, and its connection with the Upper One, he feels pleasure, confidence.
So, recognizing the greatness of godliness, because it is a higher degree, can serve me as pleasure without receiving from Him. Take a great person, I bring him a cup of tea, how I enjoyed bringing him a cup of tea. Today, a friend brought me a cup of tea, where is he? Not here? No. Oh, he brought me a cup of tea, and he asked, Is there enough sugar? Is it dark enough? Is it right like this?"I really felt that he respects me, right, but where does he get the strength to respect me? After all, he's not a saint, right, he regards me as great – by bringing a cup of tea, he gets his sustenance from it. This is between us, he doesn't know, he feels pleasure. So, do I care where he felt pleasure from, whether I have an opportunity to give a cup of tea and feel pleasure, or I have an opportunity to take ten shekels from him, and instead of giving him a cup of tea and feel pleasure? There's no difference.
So, what, the Creator wants to change my kind of sustenance, so that instead of enjoying His light directly, I would give and receive the same pleasure from that, what's the difference here? What is there to exchange, a cow for a donkey, nothing, there's no difference. If you examine his body, the friends body, you will see that his body received the same excitement, let's say of ten shekels, sorry for putting it this way, well, let's say a hundred shekels, as it would have received for itself. The difference is that this is something eternal, something unlimited. When a person receives pleasures from bestowing, beyond that he also has the standing of being the bestower, like the Creator. We cannot describe what is this state, because it's above our nature; in other words, it's not that I give and receive, or simply receive. Rather the point is to rise to the degree of godliness.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (58:34) If I need to annul myself before a great one, then where do I get the desire to be like Him, I annul myself?
M. Laitman: You annul yourself, from annulling yourself before the great one, you will not get a desire to be like him, that's true. We see it here in this world, if you crave pleasures, you annul yourself before him – receive pleasures, that's the end of it. What do you care about it, at all? You annul yourself because it is a means, but if you annul yourself because you want him to have it good, then you begin to study Him, to know Him, Know the God of your father and serve Him. You must know His deficiencies, when you begin to know His deficiencies, to absorb His deficiencies, you absorb deficiencies of bestowal. You already become like someone else, you're incorporated with his desires to bestow, you're already replacing your inner software.
Student: But I'm still doing it so that He will?
M. Laitman: I give and give and give in order to receive and receive and receive, that is perfectly fine, right, that is in this world. But if in order to give, I need to know what he lacks, and I begin to connect precisely with Him, then what does He lack, what does He want? He wants me to have it good, he wants to give to me like this: He wants – I connect to His deficiency of bestowal, it turns out that by this, I acquire new vessels from him, truly of bestowal – from this, I acquire a different nature.
Student: How does this develop these vessels in me? I connect only to these vessels of the Upper One, it's as my friend will learn really well how to?
M. Laitman: This means that we acquire the first nine, which really join me, without this I am only the black point of Malchut. I acquire the first nine and then when I have the first nine together with Malchut, I can be like Him.
Student: It's not clear to me what a friend can say?
M. Laitman: It cannot be clear, it cannot be clear, for that, we need to cross the barrier, it's a parting of the Red Sea, a miracle! Until we enter a second nature, we still cannot say it. All my words are just to, you know, to soften the air, right?
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (01:01:37) If the body receives pleasure from giving to a great one, then why does the will to receive resist it so much? Why does it still prefer to receive rather than give? If from giving to a great one it feels the same pleasure, to the same extent as in receiving for myself, then why is there a difficulty here?
M. Laitman: Giving to a great one gives unlimited pleasure, unlimited, the problem is that there are no great ones next to you. Rather you feel yourself great, that's it, if you felt someone as great, what does great mean? Great means that in your understanding, your feeling, he can fill you, this is called great, that's it. What does great mean? A higher degree, such that if you cling to it you feel good, this is called great.
Give billions of people such a feeling and you will see how they cling to someone and are like this, you know, only to belong to Him, only to be attached to Him. Because by this they fill their feeling of security, of tranquility, of the future. Today, everything is assured, everything is good, it's fine, you know, like chicks under their mother. They sit like this, you know, with the wings and everything, she sits over them, they don't need anything more, it's natural. The problem is that there are no great ones, that is why the common people are miserable. There was Ben-Gurion, something, at least someone like Ben-Gurion, afterward they made a disgrace of him, too.
Student: There are none?
M. Laitman: There are none, whoever you think is great, you see, turns out to be an inflated balloon.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (01:03:42) It's great in my uncorrected feeling. How to make him be great in the right quality?
M. Laitman: People come out of a labor camp in Siberia or somewhere, they want to stay there, they want to stay, they don't want to go outside, Why should I go outside for? I know there is work here, there is a regime here, I'm under this regime, I cling to my, to the great one and I get my peace and I'm done. Great people feel this way, not just those who don't, who know nothing in life, great ones. They stay there in place, they can leave freely. What's the matter, you have millions of kilometers where you can go and live wherever you like. He doesn't want to, he wants to stay here. A great degree, it doesn't matter what it rules over or in what way is it good or bad if we really accept it as great. This is according to nature, therefore, the feeling of the root automatically brings us its qualities.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (01:05:02) What is the difference between the greatness of the Creator and the greatness of the friend?
M. Laitman: The greatness of the friend, if you make him great, he's no longer a friend, he's already a Rav, literally great. Anyone greater than you is called a Rav, it can be the Creator, it can be a teacher, it can be a friend, doesn't matter. Whomever you choose as great, what do you mean, doesn't matter? Whomever you choose.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (01:05:39) We learned here in the article, there was a quarrel between the herdsmen of Isaac and the herdsmen of Gerar, which is the will to receive and the will to bestow. And before that, there was the article, then the children struggled within her, which is also, as it were, the same thing. Are these different discernments?
M. Laitman: No, I can't get into it now, I only want to say one thing: I see that of all the people sitting here, the one doing good work is this friend. He sits and laughs and makes everyone laugh. Maybe everyone only gets annoyed by it and doesn't want to look at his face. What is this, he's making faces at us, look what he's doing. But if you don't look at it in such a way, you decide in advance how you want to receive the light of his face, right? See what work he's doing to awaken in someone else, whether he succeeds or not is another matter. But to awaken in you a good mood, a good feeling, a good attitude toward what you hear from him. He's trying, whether he doesn't yet know how to do it well, or it depends on us, it's something else, but he's trying.
I haven't seen any other face here, including that friend, someone laughing, happy that he's sitting here, and he was given from heaven such privileges: to sit and study and hear such things. I haven't seen anything like that here, I see beaten down, miserable people who were simply gathered up, lifted out of bed and brought here, they are really suffering. This is not what we said we need to do toward one another, right? You awaken nothing by this and afterward you ask, What is there for us to do, what do we need? That is why I say if you can no longer decide together, maybe each one should go off to his own corner, sit quietly, and then start thinking about what is really demanded of him. Maybe you talk too much and don't manage to think about what you're talking about; somehow that is what needs to be done. Then there'll be no question of what to talk about at the gathering of friends, where will we get more, where else is there something more to do, what do you mean, something else to do, understand?
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (01:08:21) You said that by serving the Creator, we gradually acquire His vessels. Now, if I do such work with a friend, as it were, how can I demand from him?
M. Laitman: If we are the Creator's servants, we receive His greatness, meaning His qualities; if I serve a friend, what qualities can I receive from the friend, he's screwed up as I am, right, so is it what you think when you're going to serve him? Then he's not greater than you, and if you think it is greater than you, and it's worthwhile for you to serve him. Then precisely that same importance you gave him by him being greater than you, you will acquire that same quality, you don't understand? Let's say I think about you that you're more straight than me. I steal above 100 shekels, up to 100 shekels I don't steal, and you steal only if it's above 1,000, up to 1,000 shekels, no, that's greatness – I'm speaking seriously! That's greatness, if I think about this well, I see this as a great thing, each has a limit, your limit is 10 times my limit. It's not a joke, I'm telling you, you will see what the difference between levels in each and every one and each and every thing is, how this is very important and decisive. So, I want to adhere to you in order to receive from you, this quality. How can you hold back up to 1,000 shekels and not steal? Meaning, to think about the Creator 10 times more time, to think about spirituality, to be devoted to it 10 times. In everything, you can say what the multiple of 10 is, do you know what that is?
So if I think that you are such, I don't check you, it seems to me that it's like that, I made you great in my eyes by this. Then I already begin to acquire this quality whether it's in you or not. You don't need to come and teach me, You know what? I'll teach you how not to steal 2,000 shekels. No, I don't need that study from you, rather, to the extent in which I myself depict yourself as great, that greatness is what I acquire. You can be a liar and steal whatever you see you take, that's not important.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (01:11:17) If I work with the Creator in this way, so I'm working with something real?
M. Laitman: That's how you work also with the Creator because you don't see Him. You work that way with a friend and with the Creator and whoever you can. Then you come to a statement which you say, You must show me Your greatness, Your greatness. Why? Maybe in such a way, like I am with a friend, I will do with the Creator all the time – imagine Him as being great like this and like that. No, the quality in order to bestow, you won't acquire by that, you won't be able to buy in order to bestow. Just like from a friend, you can acquire the quality in order to bestow? The fact that you're not going to steal up to a thousand shekels in place of a hundred Shekels, that's considered that you received qualities of bestowal? God forbid! Your calculation changed, where spirituality is more important and great than corporeality. It's worthwhile to benefit from spirituality than to benefit from corporeality. You made a different evaluation: it's worthwhile for you to work there in place of here, better sustenance, the bigger Lo Lishma is there. But to move from this Lo Lishma to Lishma, you must have Him revealed. To truly acquire His quality and not what you imagine because you can imagine only from your desire to receive. It will always be Lo Lishma, it will always be in the desire to receive, the desire to receive.
Student: Why will I have a deficiency for it to be revealed?
M. Laitman: Why will you have a desire for Him to be revealed? Because you will feel that the surrounding light that's coming to you, that what you have is not real – that it's not Lishma, that it's in order to receive. The surrounding light will give you, in addition to your Lo Lishma, a grace of Kedusha. So that you will want to do something completely disconnected from yourself. That's the quality that the light gives, it's something a person doesn't feel.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (01:13:41) A person that's suffering and gets blows, so he feels the greatness of the Creator. But when he comes out of that state, he usually loses that sensation. How can you keep that feeling?
M. Laitman: A person is in sufferings, blows, and with that, does he feel something, you're saying? Or not? The greatness of the Creator.
Student: Feels.
M. Laitman: He feels? Well, it could be that he doesn't feel, I'm asking you? Oh, so in your case you want to say that he feels together with the big blows, that it's coming from the Creator. So what are you asking?
Student: When he comes out of the blows, and the state gets better, so he forgets.
M. Laitman: Wait, so first of all, we need to understand that we don't forget, and we don't remember, and we don't do anything. We are given in our mind, in our heart, conditions from above. So I'm asking you, how do you depict this machine called an Adam and what's in it? What did you enter into it, what pipes did you connect? Does he feel in his heart bad, blows, and in his mind he feels that there is a Creator or not?
Student: That there is a Creator.
M. Laitman: So he received those two inputs – what are you asking about that? Then he's moved to another state, disconnected from the line that he's in. He feels good without feeling that there's a Creator, yes? So what do you want to say: what does he want to distinguish between this state, where he was given the system that's called a person with a feeling of suffering and the feeling of a Creator, relative to the state in which he was given the system where he only feels good in place of suffering?
Student: Well, so what from above is asked that a person will feel? What discernment should he make?
M. Laitman: What does he get if he cleans this from that, equalizes this with that? Those details are not enough for me, it's not enough because he doesn't have what to compare, what is he comparing? That before he felt – you could say it this way: Earlier I felt suffering, with that I felt the Creator; now I feel good, and I don't feel the Creator. Good doesn't feel the Creator, can such a result be? It depends what he's comparing, do you understand? You're not giving me enough details, enough data. We'll study cybernetics.
All right, guys, let's go study! I'm speaking seriously, the bodily systems work in such a very simple way: if you start dividing it into a scientific way, what is put into a person and where, and you compare states, you see what he's missing.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (01:16:51) Is the best way to reach greatness of the Creator through the greatness of the friend? And if so, can I relate to everybody in the group equally?
M. Laitman: You don't need to recognize in the group the greatness of the friend. Where do you start even starting with greatness, where do you know someone in the group, even? You need to depict to yourself that your friend is great, to imagine each and everyone. You can't measure anything in a real manner; if you go by your intellect and your feeling, everyone is zeros, who's even here, there's no person, there's no Adam here. That's how you relate to the whole world, because that's the, I, of a person, that's the godly part of, from above, the, I, in us. That's why a person feels himself as individual. All the world, who's the world altogether? I constantly dream in my dreams that I am going for a stroll in the whole world and there's no one. I enter a very big city, and there's no one there; I, store, some something, I go for a stroll, there's no one altogether, it's, I, alone. That's actually what a person is, that's it.
So, how can I ever feel just like that, that someone is greater than me? Even the Creator is not greater than me, but I'm willing to think that He is great under the condition that He'll give me. That is the – that's how it is with the, I, in us, which is the only foundational thing that doesn't change – it'll only change later in the final correction. That's the stony heart. So to imagine some friend or someone next to me that is great? No, sometimes I really see that, but when I say it that way, it immediately brings me a problem: where am I here? Either I have to adhere myself to him, so it kind of, because it belongs to him, then it's mine as well. Or in some way to lower him, because I have something else that's greater than him, etc. Meaning, the work upon the greatness of a friend is work, and the more you depict him as great, you will be impressed by your imagination. That's why I'm saying we need to act towards one another, besides that inner acting that you have to do, that everyone's great and I'm small, make this external game as well towards others. So that everyone will be impressed from you, and by that it will return to you their impression, and you'll receive it in truth. Because what you feel from others, your body is impressed.
You see what they're putting into the TV these days? From morning to night, all kinds of jokes and comedy, why? Because the world is messed up completely; it lost the past, the future, there's nothing all day. From morning to night, if you hear the truth, it's just trouble. In place of that, look at what programs – entertainment, entertainment, entertainment – and people hold on a little bit to it. Psychologists understand this, and they work with this falsehood. Ask that friend, Hollywood and all those things, what is it? He once said that during the Great Depression in the 30s in North America, people, instead of buying bread, they bought tickets to the movies, to see something. What's the movie: how some rich person is walking around with some rich woman, and how they're entertained in life. Each of them feels that he's satiated, that he's good, he's like that, that's what a person lives, from that lie.
M. Laitman: (01:21:21) So why don't you want to use this? You're a real person and you can't? Well, if you use this wisely, you will relate to it as a person to your beast, from above downwards, do you understand? You look at yourself, I have a beast. This beast is tormenting my life. How can I make this beast be such that it will serve me? So, I have no choice, I have to simply feed it lies, like that carrot ahead of the bunny that's running. Or where they put a bunny in front of the dogs when they're racing – each, you understand? Yes, do you understand, you have to do that to your body. And why don't we do this? We have nothing to talk about. Why are we gathering? I don't know. For, what for? Is that how he spoke?
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (01:22:33) The imagination is the only thing we can use?
M. Laitman: Of course, not the imagination, that's called a serious attitude. The correct and mature way to the beastly body, to our animal and how to truly operate it. I don't know how we call it, how to tame, to train – you tame a dog!
Song: (01:29:16)