The
transcript
has
been
transcribed
and
edited
from
English
simultaneous
interpretation,
thus
there
may
be
potential
semantic
inaccuracies
within
it.
Daily
Morning
Lesson:
November
19,
2026
Part 2: Baal HaSulam. Study of the Ten Sefirot. Vol. 1. Part 2. Inner Observation. Item 78.
Student: Alright, we are continuing to study The Study of the Ten Sefirot. Let's open our books, first of all. We are in Volume 1, Part 2, Inner Observation, we are in Item 78. We are in Item 78. On the Internet, you can go to the Study Material and go right to the link.
What will we study today? Today, Rav will explain to us how the screen works, how it raises reflected light, what is reflected light, what does the height of the reflected light depend upon. We call it, The height of the degree. The more, the higher the reflected light, what does it depend upon? The height of the reflected light? The coarseness of the screen. The greater the coarseness, such the reflected light rises higher. Accordingly, also the vessel can receive more light, that's how it's built. Rav will explain this in detail, with the example about the worlds, about the world of Adam Kadmon, and the four phases of direct light, what awaits us is a very rich lesson.
Reader 2: All in all, we're speaking about the response of the created being on our behalf, on our response. That's why I want to say that it's very important that during the lesson, to discover our common deficiency. We need questions, we need, after the lesson, to respond to what we got during the lesson, together, in the right way, in a mutual way. To feel all the friends as much as possible that we're in one action during the lesson. It's important to prepare questions, to prepare answers, to anything that we can share with all the friends, we must make these efforts when we study together, A short clip of a preparation, for Rav to prepare us:
M. Laitman: (02:51) Just like now, we don't feel for the time being any pressure from the upper light, from the Creator, from the upper system, because we don't have screens, we have no resistance. The moment we have resistance, we start to feel the way the spiritual system relates to us, upon us. For this, we need to connect, to attend to the group and to start working with the upper light in order to bestow to the Creator, to truly bestow to the Creator, together. Then, we will start to feel how much He's pressing us and how we can pressure Him in return. But first of all, connection between us.
Reader 2: Only in the connection between us, we draw the light; only in the connection between us, we can draw the light and resemble the upper one. Let's enter the lesson together!
_______________________________
Reader: Study of the Ten Sefirot. Vol. 1. Part 2. Inner Observation. Item 78.
Reading: (04:16) The reason why phase three lacks the Keter.
The reason for the absence of the level of Keter in the second emanated being is that it does not have the coarseness of phase four in phase four, which, with respect to the reflected light, is the Keter in phase four. For this reason, the screen pushed back the upper light only from Hochma downward, meaning that measure that was intended to enter phase three in phase four. Conversely, there would not be expansion in Keter of phase four, even if the screen did not detain it, since the vessel that drew the upper light did not draw more than from Hochma and below to begin with. Hence, the screen did not push the light of Keter back, but only from the light of Hochma downward. Thus, the light of Keter is absent from this reflected light. Because the reflected light lacks the light of Keter, the light of Keter of the upper light is absent there, as well, since no light can clothe in the emanated being without reflected light to clothe it, as it is its vessel of reception (Part 2, Inner Observation, Item 21). This is why it only has the level of Hochma.
M. Laitman: (05:53) Clear, right? The upper light comes, direct light, and it depends on which coarseness the vessel uses, according to that, the reflected light can return. If it uses the coarseness of Phase four, the screen is right here, Masach screen, so the reflected light then goes up to Keter ,if it's still Phase three. So, to Hochma. If it's Phase Two, so it's till Bina; Phase one, till Zeir Anpin, and if it's coarseness of root, so it uses the Malchut. What does that mean? This is what the vessel can attain, this is attainment, as much as it can resemble the Creator and according to that, which coarseness he can use. So, it turns out that who is greater than his friend, his inclination is greater, too.
Reader: Item 79.
Reading: (07:26) Any drawing is done by phase four; this is why she needs a screen, so the light does not expand into phase four.
The rule is that any extension of light must be only in phase four in the emanated being, even though there is no intention to draw light into there. The reason is that the coarseness, which is above phase four, is unfit for extension (Part 2, Inner Observation, Chapter Five, Item 56). Even phase one in phase four is more suitable for extension than the real phase three, which is above, meaning more refined than all of phase four. Therefore, if all the coarseness has vanished from phase four, there is no one there to draw light from Ein Sof, and the light stops there entirely. Since the extension must be done with phase four, while at the same time, she must guard herself so that the light does not expand into her own phase due to the restriction on phase four, therefore, she established in herself the screen that guards that matter, since when the light expands and reaches phase four, the screen awakens and pushes that part of the light back to its root, and that part which is pushed back does not disappear, but is turned into reflected light, meaning that from it are the vessels of reception for the upper light.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (09:42) What does it mean to use coarseness?
M. Laitman: To use coarseness, you see, as much as the coarseness is greater, this is the screen that separates. So, as much as he uses greater coarseness into phase four, see? Then according to that, with his reflected light he can attain a greater spiritual discernment. If there's less of coarseness, phase three, so he reaches a less degree. This is four, three, two, one, and root. Greater coarseness is a greater will to receive, the Klipot, the shells are greater that participate. He overcomes them and turns them into holiness, so it's bigger desires, it's all about using the desire. The wisdom of Kabbalah, the wisdom of reception, teaches the created being how to use his desire because, except for that, there's nothing. The created being must be above his desire and use, take advantage, take control, to aim, to lead his desire to whatever he decides above the desire. Because except for the desire, there are no means.
When we start discovering this, we see that we're not able to do anything. I'm in my desire. Do I surrender, do I? It's better to be dead than alive, they can kill me, I can't do anything. That's how a person feels himself, discovers himself as – that the desire is everything, what can I do? So then, if he reaches such a conclusion, he starts turning to the upper force to help him overcome his desire, to rise above his desire. Then he gets that force from above, it's written that, The hero won't defeat with his own force, that's impossible. Then he gets the force of the light from above, and by that, he can control. So he controls to the extent that he receives the forces from above, like the small one who gets something from the great one, and that's why he can do it.
But to the extent that you surrender, that you're dependent, that you adhere to the upper one, to that general force of bestowal, you have an ability to be in bestowal, and in that, control the desire. You must connect, hide from your own desire in the bestowal, in the quality of bestowal, and as much as you incorporate from that quality, you can work on the desire – only like that. Then, if so, so what is that hero that overcomes? He's a hero, a Gibor, one that overcomes. That, above all disturbances, he will connect to the upper one in order to get forces from him. Not one who overcame himself, the hero, the Gibor, is that even though there are disturbances, he connects to the upper one. The person himself, with his own desire, can't do anything; that's why, when we look at all these pictures that I draw here, all these drawings, nobody can do this on their own. A screen, coarseness, restriction, goes up, goes down, you can speak, obviously, within the ego, what's more important or less important/where you gain more, where you gain less. So, you can interpret the whole wisdom of Kabbalah in an egoistic manner, of course. The more you invest, the more you get. So, everything's great.
Reader: Item 80.
Reading: (14:46) With respect to the extension of light, phase four and the screen are as one.
Regarding the extension of light from Ein Sof, phase four and the screen on her are one because the hardness of the screen lies on the coarseness in phase four. Hence, in most cases, we mention only the screen. Regarding the extension of light, it necessarily refers to both. To keep our words brief, we, too, will name the extension of the light from Ein Sof only after the screen. Regarding the emergence of the degrees from one another, we will also refer to it with the name refinement of the coarseness, although it actually refers to the hardness in the screen. Remember that it refers to the levels of the coarseness in phase four, which make four levels of hardness in the screen.
M. Laitman: (15:57) What happens in the wisdom of Kabbalah? In order to keep it brief, the language, it's a big problem in the wisdom of Kabbalah. Because, if we will call every word, use it correctly and – how do I say it?
Student: Expression?
M. Laitman: Yes, the way you express something. So, you'll get really long sentences, and in the end, it makes understanding very difficult of their inner content. That's why Kabbalists, after it is clear to them what they're speaking about with each other. They use a lot of shortening of the language, they make it very brief; and it's clear to us that without the matter of creation, without the will to receive, ou can't do anything. We already use this refinement, screen, coarseness, beating, intensity, everything. We only have to relate to the will to receive. Also, the light is a phenomenon in the will to receive, and darkness, and hardness, and refinement, and direct light, and reflected light. Each and every word can be in its foundation, it can only be clear if we connect it to our matter, the will to receive. There is nothing else, but that's why this will to receive, we usually don't mention it when we work in the will to bestow. No, the will to bestow, it's great, it's pure, it's refined, bestowing in order to bestow, intending to bestow, reflected light, screen. What are we speaking about in the end? About the will to receive that has all kinds of changes in our corrections, only the will to receive.
Not to think that something can take place without a desire because without a desire there's no creation, there's nothing to talk about. All the phenomena we read about in the books of Kabbalah, I'm not even speaking about this world; it's all a feeling in the desire. Everything Kabbalists say is the matter and the form dressed in the matter, and the matter is the desire. That's why, if we say the screen refines, the screen goes down, the light expands, there's a beating between the lights, there's the ascending of the screens, ascending of the screens – it's all words, and incorrect words, they're incorrect; but we're on purpose, between us we agreed that we're going to use these words in order to keep the language brief, Not to mention every time the will to receive, which is the matter of creation, and a certain coarseness that upon it the screen can ride, what is the screen? The force that works in the coarseness, that gets it from the light, from the Creator, what is the light in the Creator? Something that happens on the screen, an opposite feeling from the matter of the – if we'll start explaining it that way, we won't finish. We'll have to, every detail, tell the whole story of the wisdom of Kabbalah.
That's why there's a shortening, but after you shorten it, he reminds us every so often, not to forget that it all, it's from from the desire, within the desire, that's where it's happening. So, we're saying the Creator, who is the Creator? What's felt in the desire. So who is the Creator? Come and see, the special degree that the desire can get. The tallest form that it can receive, what does it mean, unique, high? Because there's a different form, that is opposite, that this is how we measure one compared to the other, that's it. Different forms in the desire.
M. Laitman: (20:36) Also, here, we see on these drawings, that as much as we use the coarseness more, what am I actually doing here? Look, what's happening: the direct light comes to me as much as I use the coarseness more, right? This is the way I use the coarseness; using coarseness, as much as I use the coarseness more, I give the upper light, I give the upper light. I let it copy in the desire a picture, a picture, and this picture, I call it Keter, that's it. There's a form, a form, I got a certain form inside the desire; now, here above, there's a desire, and below they say there's a desire, right? This is the matter, using the matter, using the coarseness, this is the matter. And above, it's not matter, it's a light, reflected light. You see, it's written, Reflected light. There's no such thing as reflected light, it's the form that I get, the depiction I get in my own matter.
So, I use the coarseness, and in that coarseness I get the form – except for the coarseness, I have nothing, except for my desire I have nothing. But this is how I feel, this is how it's depicted in me. I use my coarseness, my matter, and I get a form, and then I adhere to the matter and adhere to the form. But it's all only in my coarseness, that's where it gets clarified: a person has nothing else, it's like we learned that we have Rosh, we have the Rosh and the Guf in the Partzuf. This is the Rosh, above, right, Rosh, and this is the Guf. The Guf is phase four, from the Peh of Galgalta and below, it's phase four. So, why do I suddenly have a Rosh? So, there is no Rosh, the Rosh, when does it happen? When I started, after the first restriction, to think what I'm going to do with my coarseness, with my desire, then I get a Rosh. Meaning, I'm working in the same coarseness, only that I want in it to resemble the Creator, and I'm planning how to do it; so that's called the Rosh but actually, it's only the will to receive.
When can we say about the phases root, one, two, three, four? When phase four comes out and starts feeling and discovering what it includes, what's in it, then it says, I guess that what's in me is me getting an impression from something on the outside. Who is He? The Emanator. How does He work on me? As root, one, two, three, four – where do I know that? Because in phase four is where I discover that, only in phase four, and then from phase four, we can start having this assumption that before phase four, I guess there's three more phases, as if, because I never really know what happened before phase four, I discover it in phase four.
M. Laitman: (25:10) Meaning, we are working with the will to receive only, that's why it's called the wisdom of reception, the wisdom of Kabbalah. That anything for or against all the different forms we learn about, we're only learning in the will to receive. So, also bestowal is in the will to receive, and the Creator is felt in us as a form of bestowal that we attain: Come and See." Outside of that, we can't imagine that there is such a thing, we can never imagine the Creator outside of myself. The Creator is a form of bestowal that I attain: if I don't attain, there's no Creator. I can say, Yes, I heard something like that exists. If the measure of bestowal in me, if I start feeling something like that a bit, so I say, Hmm, I guess there's some Creator, and He's concealed. That's what takes place in my desire.
Like Baal HaSulam says, We have such an imagination that there's something outside of us, and that's simply an imagination of something outside of us, and he says we have to thank the Creator for giving us this illusion, because it's helping us advance, why? It helps me understand that something exists outside of me. Then me and that something outside of me, I can, upon that from these relationships, we can start growing. If I understand, if I think that it's all happening in me, only in my material, so I couldn't grow. I must imagine, depict something outside of me, so all these words are only from the material, and what happens on the material.
Reader: Item 81.
Reading: (27:55) The emergence of the degree of Hochma from phase three.
The emergence of the degree of Hochma from the degree of Keter has already been explained in detail above. The first ten Sefirot emerged after the restriction by the encounter of the upper light with the screen that consists of the complete coarseness in phase four (Part 2, Inner Observation, Item 64). For this reason, it raised reflected light in the entire level up to the root, which is called Keter. Once that degree was completed with Rosh, Toch, and Sof, a part of the coarseness in the screen was refined from phase four to phase three (Part 2, Inner Observation, Item 74). Because the screen acquired a change of form, it is regarded as having gone outside the degree of Keter. Then, by the encounter of the light of Ein Sof with that screen which was refined to phase three, a second ten Sefirot emerged, whose level is only up to Hochma, lacking Keter (Part 2, Inner Observation, 78).
M. Laitman: (29:12) What's he saying? Like we learned from Galgalta, that after Galgalta has expanded until the Tabur. There was a striking of the inner light and surrounding light on the screen that stands at the Tabur and won't let the light expand anymore. It has to refine, and then the refinement reaches a state as it was before; when the screen reaches through the refinement, it comes to the Peh of the Partzuf, so here, again the direct light illuminates and by the surrounding light, when it refines. Here with the direct light, it understands that it needs to descend again according to its degree and start receiving light in order to bestow, again.
Meaning, the internal and surrounding lights keep playing with the coarseness, and in this way, this coarseness keeps using itself in order to resemble the bestower more and more. And it turns out that from instead of the coarseness of phase four, you get a Partzuf of coarseness of phase three. That the light also expands, the inner light, and the surrounding light comes, and it also obligates the screen to refine, and again enter this calculation with a direct light. The direct light lowers it to a lesser degree from phase two to phase one, and again it enters a coupling by striking and expands. Again the surrounding light works and causes another refinement, and this way the inner light and the surrounding light play with a screen.
Meaning you can say this: that there's a vessel, meaning coarseness, and a screen, coarseness. Here, there's direct light, and on the other hand, you have reflected light, and these lights constantly work on the vessel. And by this, they shake it up – when there is no coarseness anymore, from four, three, two, one, root, when it reaches the root, so between direct light and reflected light, there's no resistance anymore. Then, there's nothing to strike upon, then by this, it all ends. Meaning after Phase two, we'll have one, after one, we'll have root, and in the root already, there's no striking of inner light and surrounding light, and all those actions end.
Reader: Item 82.
Reading: (33:03) The emergence of the degree of Bina from phase two.
Once that degree of Hochma was completed with Rosh, Toch, and Sof, the surrounding light refined another part of the coarseness of the screen, meaning from phase three in phase four, to phase two in phase four. That new screen of phase two in phase four is considered to have gone outside the degree of Hochma for the same reason mentioned concerning the degree of Keter (Part 2, Inner Observation, Item 76). From the encounter of the upper light with that new screen of phase two, new ten Sefirot emerged at only the level of Bina, lacking Keter and Hochma.
M. Laitman: It's the regular actions we always learned about many times. And the new friends don't want to ask anything?
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (34:12) What's the difference between this coarseness that we're speaking about that you drew now, four, three, two, one, root, and the coarseness that we have in this world?
M. Laitman: Okay, good, what is coarseness? Coarseness is something that doesn't disappear. We learned that the coarseness doesn't refine, the screen refines. So, what happens to us, are we in the same coarseness as in Ein Sof? If it doesn't refine, where does it disappear to? Where is that coarseness that disappeared from Galgalta and is in AB, and from AB to SAG, where is it? It disappears from the usage in the Partzuf: now I have a coarseness of Ein Sof. What do I see, what do I feel? I feel, let's say, 10 grams of corporeal Aviut, that's what's being revealed. The form that is revealed in these 10 grams, this form is called Michael Laitman, that's a form. All in all, from this great coarseness, that's what's revealed. You can increase it and increase it, the coarseness, part is revealed as we learned by a human development and part already through the relation to the light, to the Creator.
But all in all, what we do is, from zero, after the shattering of the vessels and onward, what was in our roots and force, we discover coarseness. Only from that we have recognition, understanding, development. From the recognition of the coarseness, if there's no coarseness, there's no matter; if there's no matter, so there's nothing. Also, the Creator is in the matter, also, the created being is in the matter – it's all revealed towards the matter. That's why the coarseness isn't refined, it disappears from recognition, from feeling, or revealed. That's why the greater his friend, his inclination is greater because without the inclination, a big one, you can't be great.
Question (Petah Tikva Center): (37:12) I'm asking about a state, where during the time you maybe harmed this coarseness. You did, I did, let's say, many diets, or I abstained from?
M. Laitman: Oh well.
Student: What happens in such a state?
M. Laitman: By a diet, you just added coarseness I see, now that you harmed it, because you thought that by that you could be younger, stronger. So the desire became bigger, you lost a few kilos from your flesh, but the desire had an addition. You could ask about coarseness, let's say, I'm old, I'm weak, I don't have a desire for anything, until you die. Where does that coarseness go to? So we say, it reincarnates, it's revealed again on a greater and greater degree. It doesn't refine, it doesn't disappear from the world, it's only revealed towards the created being. And never, it never goes back to smaller states, even in elders that supposedly their desires wane out, it's not called that these desires become smaller. We'll learn what the benefit of old age is because sometimes a person for 30 years, he is getting old, right? I see people that are 50 and they're old, and maybe they'll live till they're 80. For what, really, what's the need? Childhood, I understand, the person invests forces and he learns, and he has a need to do it gradually, not to be born in such a way. Just like we were born in such a way, we say in our correction, in this correction, we need to reach gradually that I understand, and I do, and I want all these things. But what's the benefit of old age? We'll learn about it and we'll see that the coarseness is what determines, the revelation of the coarseness is what determines this whole process in our life. So, you can get fatter, by that you're not going to add coarseness.
****End of Lesson***